Membrey was originally selected by the Sydney Swans with pick No. 46 in the 2012 National Draft, before crossing over to St Kilda at the conclusion of the 2014 season.
Since the move, Membrey has gone on to play 71 of his 72 games at the saints and boot 129 goals. In a forward line that has had a lot of change, Membrey has been the constant performer kicking 44, 38 and 33 goals over the past three seasons.
Another strong pre-season has Membrey in good shape for 2019 which has seen the season start with two wins and four Goals for Membrey.